MOND (Modified Newtonian Dynamics) Was Unnecessary: Solving Galactic Rotation Curves with "Two Illusions"

Dark matter—the invisible ghost that makes up most of the matter in the universe.
The catalyst that first prompted serious discussion about its existence was the "Galactic Rotation Curve Problem."

Stars located far from the center of a galaxy should orbit more slowly because the central gravity weakens (just as planets further out in our solar system orbit more slowly).
However, actual observations show that even at the very edges of galaxies, the rotational speed of stars does not drop at all.
To explain this phenomenon, it was hypothesized that "an invisible source of gravity (dark matter) must envelop the galaxy."

Galaxy rotation curve

On the other hand, there is a powerful competing theory that argues, "Dark matter doesn't exist; the laws of gravity themselves are wrong."
That theory is "MOND (Modified Newtonian Dynamics)."

MOND attempts to explain rotation curves without dark matter by modifying the laws of gravity, proposing that "while gravity normally weakens with the square of the distance, in distant regions where the gravitational acceleration falls below \(a_0\approx1.21\times 10^{−10}\text{ m/s}^2\), it only weakens linearly with the distance (1st power)."

However, the Intergeometric Theory declares that there is absolutely no need to modify the laws of gravity.
Both the "inverse 1st power gravity" and the "mysterious constant

a0a0​

" proposed by MOND are, in fact, phantoms created by two geometric illusions.

1. The First Illusion: The "Inverse 1st Power" Mirage Caused by Uniform Mass Distribution

In the simplest MOND model, the attractive force F felt by a star is expressed as the sum of the "normal inverse-square gravity" and the "apparent inverse-1st-power gravity dominant at large distances."

\[F = \frac{GM^2}{R^2} + \frac{\sqrt{GM^3 a_0}}{R^1}\]​​​

At first glance, it seems the law of gravity has changed. But what if we assume that "normal inverse-square gravity is simply acting on all matter, including dark matter"?
In other words, let's assume that the "1st power gravity (right side of the equation)" MOND sees is actually just a different way of calculating the "2nd power gravity (left side)" that includes dark matter, and set them equal to each other.

\[\frac{\sqrt{GM^3 a_0}}{R^1} = \frac{GM^2}{R^2}\]​​

Squaring both sides and simplifying, we find that the mysterious constant \(a_0\) can be expressed by an extremely simple equation:

\[a_0 = G \frac{M}{R^2} \]​

Now, let's consider this on the scale of the entire universe.
Let the distance R be the distance to the edge of the universe (the Hubble distance \(c/H_0\)).
Let the mass M be the total mass of all matter (normal matter + dark matter) inside a sphere with that Hubble distance as its radius. This is found by multiplying the universe's critical density \rho_0\) by the matter fraction (\(\Omega_{m0}\approx 0.315\)), and then by the volume of the sphere \((4\pi/3)R^3\).

Mass exists at a Hubble distance away.

Substituting this into the \(a_0\) equation yields a breathtakingly beautiful formula:

\[a_0 = G \frac{M}{R^2} = \frac{H_0 \cdot c \cdot \Omega_{m0}}{2}\]​​

(Hubble constant\(\times\)Speed of light\(\times\)Matter fraction\(\div\)2. It is an equation made entirely of fundamental cosmic parameters).

First, let's calculate using the correct early-universe Hubble constant obtained from observations (\(H_\text{0(early)}\approx 67.4\text{ km/s/Mpc}\)).

\[a_0 = \frac{67.4 \cdot c \cdot 0.315}{2}\approx 1.03 \times 10^{-10}\text{ m/s}^2\]

Astoundingly, it produced a value almost on the exact same order as the empirical constant \(a_0\approx1.21\times 10^{-10}\) set by MOND.

This is the first illusion.
If mass (including dark matter) is spread "uniformly" across the universe, misidentifying it as "gravity concentrated at a single point" causes the illusion that gravity is decaying with the "1st power of distance" rather than the "2nd power." The law of gravity had not changed at all.

2. The Second Illusion: "Stretching the Ruler" by the Hubble Tension

Now, there is still a slight discrepancy between the theoretical value of 1.03 and the observed value of 1.21.
What bridges this final gap is the second illusion: the greatest mystery in modern cosmology, the "Hubble Tension."

The Hubble Tension is a "scale illusion." When we try to directly observe the universe's expansion without realizing the decay of vacuum energy, our "observational ruler" gets stretched, making the Hubble constant appear larger (\(H_\text{0(late)}\approx 73.0\)). (For details, see the [The True Culprit Behind the Hubble Tension: How the Unnoticed "Scale Illusion" Ends the Crisis in Cosmology]).

When we observe galactic rotation curves and measure the acceleration \(a_0\), we are measuring the distances between celestial bodies using this "stretched ruler (the late-universe Hubble constant \(H_\text{0(late)}\))."

The cosmic density (M) serving as the source of mass is determined by the true Hubble constant (\(H_\text{0(early)}\)). However, the observed distance (\(R_\text{(late)}\)) is stretched by the illusionary Hubble constant (\(H_\text{0(late)}\)).
When we reflect this "ruler discrepancy" in the previous equation, it is corrected as follows:

\[a_0 = G \frac{M}{R_\text{(late)}^2} = \frac{H_\text{0(late)}^2 \cdot c \cdot \Omega_{m0}}{H_\text{0(early)} \cdot 2}\]

Let's substitute the two observed Hubble constants (73.0 and 67.4) into this equation:

\[a_0 = \frac{73.0^2 \cdot c \cdot 0.315}{67.4 \cdot 2}\approx 1.21 \times 10^{-10}\text{ m/s}^2\]

(Note: Calculated with more precise theoretical values, it becomes \(1.2234\times10^{−10}\text{ m/s}^2\).)
It perfectly matches the mysterious constant \(a_0\) proposed by MOND, down to the decimal precision.

Conclusion: MOND and Dark Matter Were Never in Conflict

The long-standing debate over galactic rotation curves—"Dark Matter vs. Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND)"—was not a case of one being wrong and the other right.

  • The reason gravity appeared to act linearly (to the 1st power of distance) was a geometric illusion caused by the "uniform distribution of dark matter (mass)."
  • The reason the MOND constant \(a_0\) took the odd value of \(1.21\times 10^{-10}\) was that the "illusion of spatial scale caused by the Hubble Tension" had crept in.

The existence of dark matter, the standard law of gravity (inverse-square law), and the Hubble Tension.
These three cosmic truths were perfectly holding hands inside a single, beautiful equation.

Further details are available under [Research & Papers].

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *